icarusi
Regular Member
- Joined
- Nov 23, 2008
- Messages
- 88
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 6
- Age
- 74
- My Satellite Setup
- Fortecstar Passion+
- My Location
- UK
I finally got a Western Digital WD TV HD unit from Tescos, the only place I could find with a no quibble return policy on it. The bad news is that it doesn't play 'native' P+ .TS files directly. If you pass them through TsRemux it will play them, unfortunately the P+ won't play those files, so you end up with two files if you want to use both the WD and the P+. Even with files remuxed via TsRemux the WD won't play the P+ 'chopped-up' files seamlessly but stops, loads and starts files in alpha numeric order. You need to use TSSplitter or tsMuxeR to join the parts for the WD TV to play them (which is slow compared to TsRemux remuxing) and then you'll probably need to use NTFS file system to overcome the FAT32 4Gb filesize limit. Fortunately Easius partitioner can write a FAT32 and an NTFS partition on the same drive which the P+ will accept, showing and usuing the FAT32 and ignoring anything on the NTFS (which 'Swissknife' couldn't do).
The TsRemuxed files I joined with TSSplitter did have some pixellated frames at the join, but the P+ doesn't always playback perfectly over the native file split points. The tsMuxeR s/w won't accept P+ .TS files although it has the function to remove parts within a file as well as top and tail. TsRemux has top and tail function only.
The navigation on the WD TV isn't good. It only has FF and FR at up tp 16x, no jumps, bookmarks or gotos, and at 16xFF often loses the time counter or the picture freezes and the counter resumes. Sometimes it locks in FF and only recovers after it's played out the entire recording. This is with the latest firmware update. That alone is cause to return the unit even without playing P+ format TS files.
The WD TV did play some current BBC HD files I recorded via my Nova HD S2 pc card and Cyberlink s/w, in the correct aspect ratio, which the Cyberlink s/w can't!
I intend to try the Asus HDP-R1 if it reappears but otherwise unless the WD TV live (both have network connectivity) gets better navigation than the WD TV I'm more likely to go the Bluray route now that prices are falling and the TsRemux/TSSplitter/tsMuxeR route seems to at least provide an alternative to 'P+ only' playback .
The TsRemuxed files I joined with TSSplitter did have some pixellated frames at the join, but the P+ doesn't always playback perfectly over the native file split points. The tsMuxeR s/w won't accept P+ .TS files although it has the function to remove parts within a file as well as top and tail. TsRemux has top and tail function only.
The navigation on the WD TV isn't good. It only has FF and FR at up tp 16x, no jumps, bookmarks or gotos, and at 16xFF often loses the time counter or the picture freezes and the counter resumes. Sometimes it locks in FF and only recovers after it's played out the entire recording. This is with the latest firmware update. That alone is cause to return the unit even without playing P+ format TS files.
The WD TV did play some current BBC HD files I recorded via my Nova HD S2 pc card and Cyberlink s/w, in the correct aspect ratio, which the Cyberlink s/w can't!
I intend to try the Asus HDP-R1 if it reappears but otherwise unless the WD TV live (both have network connectivity) gets better navigation than the WD TV I'm more likely to go the Bluray route now that prices are falling and the TsRemux/TSSplitter/tsMuxeR route seems to at least provide an alternative to 'P+ only' playback .