Its certainly been a talked about subject!!!
My personal opinion is that its coincidence about the transponder...you have two very distinct sizes of dish that you use:
The 4.2 is big enough to bring in 11778 all the time, but it also brings in everything else all the time so clear picture on all channels = no lock ups
Your smaller offset dish is nowhere near big enough to bring in the astra 2d stuff, therefore it is tuned for everything else which it brings in ok = no lock ups.
Now, you've probably had experiences with loads of 1.5-1.8m dishes which WILL cause lock ups but will also NOT bring in 11778, hence your perfectly reasonable arguement about the default transponder thing - but it also makes my auguement about weak channels
I have personally never made any connection with lock ups and the default transponder, I think it is just a weak channel thing & it just so happens that, because of our geographical location, and the way that 11778 comes in compared to the other frequencies that it makes your point. I think that there are times that out in cyprus you can have lock ups when 11778 is present (EG BBC on a 2.4m dish in SW Cyprus), but to really make the point you need to check out areas where 11778 is really strong all the time but its other channels that come in and out! (anyone out there......)
Damn it, I WILL have my Efes
Cheers
Nick