soda said:
Xerxes,
Have you considered linking the Phantom PVR with a hard disk recorder/DVD... .
Hi Soda,
Well, we've all passed a lot of water since the posting you quoted (which is nearly a year old now).
I bought a "Phantom PVR" and after a marathon struggle got it to work with my Sky digibox, more or less successfully. A few months later, though, I decided what the hell - poor old Rupert M. clearly needs my hard earned Euros, and splashed out on a Sky+.
It had occurred to me that you could use the "Phantom PVR" with a DVD recorder. But the end result would hardly be in the same class as Sky+.
Much as I bitterly resent shelling out the dosh to Sky, I have to admit Sky+ really is a very good product. And it really does change how you watch TV, in a way that the "Phantom PVR", or a DVD recorder never could.
Because it's so easy to set up a recording and play it back, I find that about the only thing I actually watch "live" these days is the news. Everything else I watch is recorded. And I find I frequently want to record 2 different channels at the same time - or watch one, whilst recording another.
The Sky+ also allows you to avoid a problem I was having the "Phantom PVR", namely missing recording the start and ends of programmes. It's not the Phantom's fault, as it relies entirely on the info sent out with a programme when it's broadcast. But it was still extremely annoying to find the first 5 minutes or so of a programme hadn't been recorded.
Incidentally, the "Phantom PVR" won't work with Sky+ at all, since the Sky+ does not send out the "program has just started" signal that the Phantom relies on.
1 year on, I reckon the best combination (for me, at least) is Sky+ and a hdd recorder (I have seen the Panasonic DMR-E85 on sale for as low as €480 recently, about 340 quid) - but clearly this is not the cheepest solution.
Regards
Xerxes