rolfw said:
The BSkyB SCR capable receivers require a smart splitter, don't the Sky Italia boxes use standard Unicable?
Well based on the above tests, it does seem Italian boxes have special software and they use standard SCR.
I have done some research on this and here are my findings (not tested on boxes)
Sky UK seems to be using a non standard SCR (I will call it bSkyB SCR) which is incompatable with any other system.
The reason they have done this is that is possibly because they wanted to upgrade apartments to work with SCR but ONLY with bSkyb's SCR so they could not be be used for Freesat. Basically it seems as if they wanted to create an incompatable systems for apartments.
In conjunction they created a system with global. This was a bit of a flop, and it is no longer available from them.
_http://www.globalinvacom.com/products/scr.php
This needs to be connected to a quattro LNB or a multiswitch.
The same unit is also available under the vision brand
_http://www.vision-products.co.uk/assets/products/datasheets/V70-400SCR.pdf
It seems to be for sale here: , which gives an idea of the price. Note the discounted price, seems to not be a big seller. (UK£99)
_http://www.satelliteandaerialsupplies.com/product/?s=vision-v70-400-scra-single-cable-router-adaptor-clearance-price
However two crowds have recently created a universal SCR that does not only bSkyb's but other standards too. This would be much better for apartment blocks, as Freesat boxes may work too. (assuming they have SCR option)
_http://teldis.co.uk/Satellite-Channel-Router-Multiswitches/scr583-satellite-channel-router-5-wire-cascade-8-user-ports-legacy-or-scr
It specifically mentions Sky's propriatory SCR protocol.
_http://www.johansson.be/en/products/mdu/dst/ms/9742.html
This product seems to have just been launched (some suppliers do not even have it yet)
One place has it at £400
No-one seems to be making an SCR LNB that is compatable with the bSkyb protocol. More worrying is that neither johansson nor teldis sell LNB's so it is less likely they will come up with an LNB version in the future.
However the good news is there is a better solution for apartments, which is fairly reasonable, considers the problems in recabling old apartments.
More interesting is that it seems as if Sky UK may be making a change to their box to allow standards SCRs
_http://www.satellitesuperstore.com/advice-page-2.htm
"
Update 30th March 12. We understand Sky TV is now putting
unicable software into Sky Digiboxes / Sky + HD."
I would caution against waiting for this. I checked my box the other day and no new option has appeared yet. Also their SCR LNB may be bSkyb protocol only and way overpriced to begin with.
I would prefer open standards, but Sky has always tried to use closed standards to create a monopoly and kill competition.
Moderation Note
Please remember - no live links to outside sites. Forum Rules.